User blog comment:IceFireWarden0/Speculations for Season 11/@comment-173.25.193.130-20130726190430/@comment-173.25.193.130-20130727052250

This whole page is speculation. I cannot offer much speculation on characters that I have no reference to. Therefore, I offer an answer that is not entirely out of the realm of possibility. How much about Allison is actually known? Her wiki says it is assumed she died, and the whole wiki is unofficial. Being beato over the head with 3 sentences does not mean you know the person. That recording was Tex, not Allison. That recording was broken promise and failure personified, what the Director remembered of her. Years apart and war will change a person. After the time apart, the Director might not even recognize her. He was chasing a shadow from his past, a person long gone, even though the person might be alive. All I am saying is Church is no more the same as the Director than Tex is the same as Allison. Epsilon became more than a copy of the Director, and Tex was a shadow, less than a copy. She was limited terribly by the Directors memory. She could have been captured, lost in cryosleep somewhere, or merely did not want to be found, or she herself could not find the Director. She was not a member of project freelancer, so the military/gov't could have stopped her from contacting him,even after returning. It was a very terrible war that was going very badly for humanity, so its possible communications were so broken down, it was impossible to get a message through either way. My speculations allude to things that are not spelled out in the series, I am not referencing anything in the series. When the war is awful and many bodies are not recovered, it is easy to assume the worst. The aliens use energy weapons, many bodies were unrecognizable or lost to space. I can see where the director would go insane and think that his girlfriend would be dead. When trillions die, one living person could be lost. To reference Halo, Master Chief was lost for years between Halo 3 and 4, and was assumed, unoffically, to be KIA. He was a Spartan, which is the only reason he was offically labeled MIA. I agree that it is unlikely, but maintain both that it could be her, and that Allison would indeed be a different person than Texas.