User blog comment:Beta-Red-Actual/That one Blue Dude - Simple theories/@comment-5189054-20120924013907/@comment-5457283-20120924014745

The Montana theory makes more sense than any other theory I've heard or read. Due to simplicity and visual facts that come together to form a basis. Is it solid? No, but it seemingly fits the puzzle pieces together. Your Tucker theory is, at best, over analylitical. Its good to keep an open mind, especially forming a speculation, but it is way to broad of a conjecture. Especially in the Red vs. Blue universe.

Thats why when I wrote this, I formed minor opinions, based on as much visual "evidence" I can get my hands on as well as detailed observation. Not based on "What if's".