Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4856748-20140810153003/@comment-4616231-20140819195825

205.206.227.102 wrote: my other theory, is that on the vague possibility that it could be allison, the director's deceased lover. as we've seen before, a death can be faked, (ie the reds and blues thinking carolina was dead). this could also possibly explain away the 'my property' issue as some sort of deranged custody agreement. Well, when the Director knew Allison he was probably a lot younger, hence why Church acts like he does instead of a direct copy of the Director - he's a younger version. If that's the case, then even if Allison was still alive, she'd be an old woman and probably moved on with her life by now.

There are two kinds of faking death - purposely becoming fake-dead, and people just thinking you're dead. The latter seems to be Carolina's case. If it was also Allison's case, I don't see why she wouldn't have returned to the Director after the war. And if she faked it purposefully, it wouldn't have anything to do with Freelancer as it didn't exist yet, so I don't she why she's deciding to get involved now.

But I'm pretty sure she's dead. She was just another soldier that the Director happened to like. Nothing special about her. I can't fathom a reason she'd fake her death. They'd have to spend a whole season just trying to explain all that.