User blog comment:IceFireWarden0/Speculations for Season 11/@comment-173.54.44.225-20130920002053/@comment-4616231-20130920042139

Then he should be congradulating the Reds and Blues because they took down the organization he would've hated the most. Seriously, I don't even see why he'd be mad at Wash, because despite being a Freelancer, Wash fucked up PF anyway.

But no. He's not an Innie. First of all, if he was, we would've seen him in the past before, or else we'd have, (quote me): "oh hey guys, here's a charachter from the past that we didn't see in the past at all!". Second, I'm not sure why I didn't think of this earlier, but, with the Innie soldiers' armor being unique to the soldier, that means they were mostly likely just meant for the animated scenes in S9 & 10, because they can't actually use that armor in the game. At the very least, if he was an Innie he would've stuck with the color scheme. But no, his voice doesn't match anyone from the past and neither does the colors of his armor. So yeah, not an Innie.