Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34266762-20190424175540/@comment-29800728-20190717135611

Solaris XD wrote: Seasons 2 and 3. Most people point to Season 5 for best BGC season (and I do love me some season 5 too), but 2 and 3 were and still are, such a blast for me to watch. Season 4 on the other hand is actually my least liked season period barring 14. Aside from the sword quest, the season was a bore and most of the jokes fell flat to me (particularly the Simmons defecting to blue team plot which dragged for way too long, went no where and only had one good joke out of it.)

Season 11 was cool too although I feel some plot elements could have been handled better. Also, I actually found the machinima crash site fights quite refreshing and enjoyable to watch actually. It was well choreographed enough to be entertaining despite lacking the flippy kicky stuff that most post-season 7 fights have.

Season 15 to me was the epitome of "Great idea, underwhelming execution." The season starts great but drops off for a while about when the Reds and Bues go to Temple's underwater base and begins to absoloutely drag. I also liked the idea of the Blues and Reds and other simulation troopers as villans, but again, felt like it was underwhelming in execution. Not to mention how anticlimatic the climax is and how they all go down with little to no fight, including temple himself. The only two who felt like they had a satisfying defeat funnily enough was surge and gene (Loco gets a pass too because heroic sacrifice). I wouldn't go as far as to say 15 was bad, it sure as shit had its great moments, but it was definetly underwhelming and disappointing to me. Season 4 is actually my favourite season from The Blood Gulch Chronicles. I just love. the story is great, the comedy is great the return to Blood Gulch is great. It's just great.

I have no bad things to say about Season 11. Just a fantastic season.

Seaon 15 is also great. I understand what you're saying and get why some people wouldn't like it. I love it. Joe did a fantastic job with it and I was so excited to see his next season. Just, how? How did he go from great with Season 15 to......Season 16? I don't get it?